home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0609>
- <title>
- May 16, 1994: Business:Dress Rehearsal, or Opening?
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- May 16, 1994 "There are no devils...":Rwanda
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BUSINESS, Page 68
- Dress Rehearsal, or Opening Night?
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> Still screenstruck after an early fling, Bronfman has Seagram
- buy a hunk of Time Warner--but just what he wants is turning
- into a Wall Street cliff-hanger
- </p>
- <p>By George J. Church--Reported by Bernard Baumohl/New York and Jeffrey Ressner/ Los
- Angeles
- </p>
- <p> It would make a great script for a movie or TV mini-series:
- company founder's teenage grandson rebels against going into
- family liquor business and vows instead to carve out his own
- career as a show-biz tycoon. But the movies and plays he produces,
- partly with his share of the family wealth, all bomb; he returns,
- chastened, to the place being held for him in the family firm.
- There he unexpectedly shows a fair executive talent and succeeds
- in keeping an already giant company growing, largely by diversifying
- beyond whiskeymaking. But he remains screenstruck, and as he
- approaches his 39th birthday next week, makes a second run at
- the glitter world--this time by launching, in alliance with
- some of the top names in Hollywood, a titanic battle to take
- over the world's biggest media and entertainment company.
- </p>
- <p> On Wall Street that scenario had a socko preview last week.
- Stock of Time Warner, the $14.5 billion movie, cable-TV, recording,
- telecommunications, magazine-publishing giant and employer of
- Madonna, Metallica, Batman and the staff of this publication,
- leaped 11% on Tuesday alone, to $40 a share. It closed the week
- at $39. Some of the recent buying came from Seagram, the beverage
- giant, which boosted its holdings to 14.9% of Time Warner's
- shares. But more came from traders reacting to a sudden storm
- of rumors that Seagram's president, Edgar Bronfman Jr., had
- finally decided to go for an outright takeover. Rumors endowed
- Bronfman with a long string of potential allies (several phone
- companies, the cable-TV firm Tele-Communications Inc. and such
- Hollywood powers as superagent Michael Ovitz and QVC chief Barry
- Diller) and even set a potential price: $55 for each of the
- 322 million Time Warner shares that Seagram does not already
- own. One story had Bronfman taking time at his wedding reception
- this year to huddle with Ovitz and Diller about takeover strategies.
- </p>
- <p> Wait, though. Like the plot of many another entertainment extravaganza,
- this one might be wildly overhyped. Perhaps Seagram is doing
- no more than Bronfman blandly asserts: making a long-term, "passive"
- investment in a company whose future earnings promise a bigger
- return than Seagram's declining liquor business. One of Bronfman's
- oldest show-business friends, movie producer David Puttnam (Chariots
- of Fire), insists it is not even the entertainment side of Time
- Warner that most intrigues Bronfman but the prospect for future
- profits on the information superhighway. Says Puttnam: "The
- idea that he has stars in his eyes is just nonsense."
- </p>
- <p> Or maybe Bronfman is aiming somewhere between a passive investment
- and an exorbitantly expensive takeover battle. Seagram might
- want to amass only enough stock to demand a voice in the company's
- varied businesses. Or maybe, deadening anticlimax though this
- thought might be, Bronfman has not made up his mind.
- </p>
- <p> In any case, a turning point seems to be close for Bronfman
- and for Time Warner chairman Gerald Levin, who are widely reported
- to have been negotiating in person. Bronfman has to decide whether
- to buy enough additional Time Warner shares to push Seagram's
- holdings past the 15% mark. If he does, Levin must ponder whether
- to activate a device known as a "poison pill" designed specifically
- to prevent any "unfriendly" investor from acquiring more than
- 15%. Essentially, the company would issue enough new stock to
- knock a 15% holding down to about 5% or less. That, in effect,
- would force Bronfman's hand: Seagram could avoid having its
- ownership diluted only by making an all-cash offer to buy up
- every last Time Warner share outstanding. At a price of $55
- a share, that would cost $18 billion--for openers. By some
- calculations, other costs associated with a takeover, notably
- assumption of Time Warner's huge debt, would force Bronfman
- and allies to come up with $35 billion or more.
- </p>
- <p> There are compromises possible too. One being talked up among
- security analysts: Seagram would buy up to 25% of Time Warner
- stock, but Bronfman would guarantee to freeze its holdings there
- for a long time and not try to unseat the present management.
- Levin in return would leave the poison pill in the corporate
- medicine cabinet and let Seagram place one or two members on
- Time Warner's 15-person board, giving Bronfman a strong voice
- but not control. At minimum, Levin will need to have at least
- some preliminary answers next Thursday for stockholders attending
- the annual meeting and asking what goes on.
- </p>
- <p> Whatever his short-range tactics, Bronfman's eventual goal might
- well be more psychological than financial--a search for success
- in some field more socially prestigious than the liquor business
- that began with grandfather Sam Bronfman. In 1919 Sam took over
- a hotel business upon the death of Yechiel Bronfman, who had
- brought the family to Canada 20-odd years earlier from Czarist
- Russia. Sam quickly took advantage of Prohibition in the neighboring
- U.S. He sold liquor to U.S. bootleggers and stockpiled much
- more whiskey; then, when Prohibition was repealed in 1933, he
- could slake American thirsts legally.
- </p>
- <p> "Mr. Sam" wound up with the foundation of a family fortune that
- has since grown to around $4 billion, but troubled by a thought
- he was still voicing decades later: "How long do you think it'll
- be before they stop calling me a goddam bootlegger?" Seeking
- respectability and reacting against the strong anti-Semitism
- of the Canadian elite, he plunged into Jewish affairs, raising
- huge sums in the 1930s and '40s to help the Zionist founders
- of what became Israel. His son Edgar Sr., who became head of
- Seagram's U.S. operations in 1957 and of the whole company on
- Mr. Sam's death in 1971, has continued that tradition. Though
- he is still chairman of Seagram, Edgar Sr. devotes most of his
- time to the World Jewish Congress, which he has headed since
- 1980. Among other things, he is credited with prompting much
- of the investigation that unmasked the Nazi past of former United
- Nations Secretary-General Kurt Waldheim. In the U.S. he has
- been an important Democratic Party supporter; he was an early
- backer of Jimmy Carter as the Georgian began his 1976 presidential
- run.
- </p>
- <p> At Seagram, Edgar Sr. accommodated changing consumer tastes
- in part by lightening blends of a leading whiskey brand, introducing
- bottled cocktails and importing wines and liqueurs. He also
- diversified into office buildings, shopping malls and other
- businesses. In 1981 Seagram bid for control of Conoco, a giant
- oil and gas producer. It lost to Du Pont Co. but came out owning
- 24.3% of Du Pont stock, today worth around $9 billion. Seagram's
- management of that investment just might indicate what role
- it could play in Time Warner. The company has made no effort
- to take over Du Pont, but it sought and got proportional representation
- on the Du Pont board. Seagram counts as part of its own profits
- not just dividends from Du Pont but a proportionate share--that is, 24%--of Du Pont's undistributed earnings. Corporate
- accounting rules permit a company to do that if it owns 20%
- or more of another firm--and that is why some stock analysts
- think Seagram may well boost its share in Time Warner past that
- threshold.
- </p>
- <p> Edgar Sr. blazed a path for his son in another way: investing
- in show business. He tried gaining control of Paramount but
- lost, then bought a big block of MGM and actually became chairman
- in 1969, only to resign after Kirk Kerkorian took over the company.
- Bronfman continued, however, to back Broadway shows (one was
- 1776) and motion pictures. In 1970 Edgar Jr., then 14, found
- a script on a table of the family's New York City apartment
- and talked his father into bankrolling Melody, a movie based
- on that script. He skipped summer camp and went to London to
- make tea and run errands for the filmmakers. Puttnam, the producer,
- remembers him wearing the same tie-dyed shirt and jeans every
- day. "He was very bright, incredibly tenacious and learned very
- fast--a very decent kid who has never been short with his
- opinions. He was absolutely determined to do things on his own."
- Edgar Jr., who acquired the nickname "Efer"--he even named
- a company Efer Productions--came back to New York long enough
- to graduate from the Collegiate School, a tony preparatory institution,
- but rather than going on to college, he decided to become a
- producer on his own. "I've fallen in love with producing and
- plan to make it my life's work," he announced while still a
- senior at Collegiate. During the 1970s and early '80s, he produced
- movies (The Blockhouse, The Border) and plays (Ladies of the
- Alamo). Some shows featured such stars as Peter Sellers and
- Jack Nicholson, but none achieved much critical or financial
- success. Bronfman was a bit luckier in a fling at songwriting.
- Dionne Warwick recorded a love song he wrote, Whisper in the
- Dark. Efer "eloped" (his word) with Sherry Brewer, a black model-actress
- and close friend of Warwick. They had three children before
- divorcing in 1991; early this year, Bronfman took a second wife,
- the daughter of a Venezuelan oil executive.
- </p>
- <p> In 1978 the young producer told an interviewer for Women's Wear
- Daily that "right now I have no interest in getting into the
- Seagram business." Four years later, though, he did just that.
- In 1986, Edgar Sr. proclaimed Efer his heir as head of the company.
- He was chosen over his older brother Samuel, who in 1975 was
- the center of a sensational kidnapping case; one of the two
- captors claimed Samuel had arranged the abduction himself to
- extort ransom money from his father. The family believed Samuel's
- angry denials.
- </p>
- <p> Edgar Jr. assumed the mantle as something of a ruler by divine
- right. Industry sources say he runs the company by fiat, not
- consensus. Says an observer: "It's the old school of `I lay
- down the law, and you obey it.'" Generally, his performance
- is rated as mixed. Says commentator Paul Gillette, publisher
- of the trade paper the Wine Investor: "He's made some moves
- that work, and others that make you go hmmm..."
- </p>
- <p> In fairness to Bronfman, he has had to battle a seemingly irreversible
- decline in Seagram's core business: because of health worries
- and life-style changes, per capita consumption of liquor in
- the U.S. has been declining for years, and even within the liquor
- category, tastes have been shifting from Seagram's old specialty,
- "brown goods" (Scotch, bourbon, blends) to "white goods" (gin,
- rum, vodka). Bronfman has tried to cope partly by shedding lower-priced
- brands to concentrate on higher-prestige liquors. Among other
- things, he has acquired Martell cognac from a French company
- and worldwide distribution rights to Absolut vodka from a Swedish
- government-controlled firm. That has helped a second strategy,
- expanding overseas operations; cognac generally and Martell
- specifically are particularly popular in the fast-growing East
- Asian market. Also, Bronfman has moved into nonalcoholic beverages,
- notably by buying the Tropicana line of fruit juices. That has
- increased revenues and profits, but at the high price of $1.2
- billion. Overall, Seagram's profits have expanded an unimpressive
- 10% in the past five years, to $650 million in the fiscal year
- ended Jan. 31, on sales of roughly $6 billion. The record looks
- better considering only earnings from Seagram's own operations,
- which grew 77% while profits from its Du Pont investment receded.
- Du Pont supplied 82% of Seagram's total profit in 1989, but
- only 21% in the most recent fiscal year.
- </p>
- <p> Still, analysts generally agree that the company will earn more
- by investing in something--almost anything--other than liquor.
- Even so, few people, including some of Bronfman's rumored allies,
- believe he wants to get into a takeover battle: raising the
- monstrous sums needed would be a strain on the wealth of even
- his family and any foreseeable teammates. On the other hand,
- singer Warwick, who remains a friend, says she has talked with
- Edgar Jr. about the "music end" of Time Warner's business and
- adds, "He really wants it--I know." After all these years,
- Bronfman has finally produced a hit, titillating Wall Street,
- if not yet Hollywood, with a first-rate mystery-suspense show.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-